Salafi Movement need of introspection and Intervention for correction

The history of campaigns and revolutionary or 
reformative movements shows that, after passage of a period of 
time, or when the scope of the effort enlarges greatly (specially 
when, by means of it, the attainment of certain advantages and 
leadership becomes apparent) then such weaknesses, unwanted 
objectives and neglect of the original goals set in, which reduce  

or even totally wipe out the true influence of the work.

To start any good idea or movement is difficult But to safeguard these Ideas and movement from loosing it path is more difficult.
After dealing these sectarian issues for last 3/12 years it is becoming apparent that salafi Movement is passing through that phase.

It is a right time for Salafi movement for introspection and this movement is in urgent need that Great Salafi Scholars should come forward to control the Salafis Flag bearer Youth to control further damage to their Movement and Damage to the Islamic Fabric caused by activities of misguided elements on the name of Salafi Dawah.

Obviously these misguided Youth has nothing to do with Salafi Ideology and no True Salafi is endorsing them.But so many subdivision among salafi so very difficult to know the true Salafi.

Still bigger problem is that these youth have become public interface and contact of Salafi Movement on internet.

Some of the key areas where these Youth needs proper Knowledge. 

CALRIFICATION

1.Please be clear these youth who are being described below constitute a good part of those who identify them as salafi on internet.

2. But they have nothing to do with true Salafi/ Salafi Ideology .

3. Please dont blame true Salafi for act of these misguided youth/

4.They are simply misguided youth having a name of salafi/Ahle Hadith and doing nuisance on the name of true Islam.

5.May Allah save Muslims from this Fitnah.

KEY AREAS WHERE THEY HAVE MISGUIDENCE......
1. There concept of Four School of Mazahib is 100% erroneous. They dont know the Process of Evolution of  Fiqh. Have no knowledge of all the Hadith  on a particular issue ..Say for example Placing hand during Salat...................

They will read one Hadith and will not read other and will go to general public Blaming that you are following Imam and I am follwing Hadith ............Sometime they will abuse the Great Imams will tell that they were not knowing Hadith
One of them has told that Imam Abu Hanifa was knowing only 3 or 17 Hadith..........How Erroneous they are......How little knowledge with flithy tongue they are.......Very erronous statements are coming on face book........

2. In Aqeedah to refute Taweel they will use so much philosphy that  will practically  Tajseem  (Anthropomorphism of Allah) ........Very erronous statements are coming on face book about Where is Allah? .....A simple matter well described by Quran hadith and Salaf like Imam Malik Rahimullah .......but they are making complex on you tube and face book discussion......

3.Branding everyone other than their sub-sub-sub ideology as Deviant Gumrah and Bidati .........

Initially they started doing against Hanafi, Shafaee, Maliki, Hnbali ....they became after Islamic Dawah Movements ....Jamaat e Islami, Tablighi Jamaat, Ikhwanul Muslimeen .....(No one is telling that these are error free movements ......Other than prophet no one is error free.......And it is duty of other Muslims to point out mistakes ....But their are clear Quran and Hadith guidelines for doing this in a good manner with love and humility.......There is no point of branding everyone as deviant.........
Now they are even not sparing Individuals who are identified as Salafi ......like Dr zakir Naik, etc.........


4. 

مُّحَمَّدٌ۬ رَّسُولُ ٱللَّهِ‌ۚ وَٱلَّذِينَ مَعَهُ ۥۤ أَشِدَّآءُ عَلَى ٱلۡكُفَّارِ رُحَمَآءُ بَيۡنَہُمۡ‌ۖ

[48:29] Muhammad (Sallallaho Alaihe Wassallam) is the messenger of Allah, and those who are with him are hard on the disbelievers, compassionate among themselves...
Some scholar with uncontrolled tongue having a special field to criticize other Scholars/Muslim Organisation/Movements  like Janab Talibur Rahman Sb ,Janab Tauseefur Rahman sb, Jnab Meraj Rabbani sb, Janab Motiur Rahman sb etc has become their Fazilatus Sheikh and Scholar of highest level.....They are always listening to them .......So their heart has become hard for other Muslims 

May Allah help the Muslim

(To be continued).

Dr zakir Naik frequently asked questions pattern is followed in muslim controversy and debates also

Dr. Zakir Naik the famous Orator used to say that Non Muslims generally has some common questions about misconception about Islam and he has prepared some 20 frequently asked questions on the issue.


This pattern is closely  followed..................... among Muslims also for controversial topics on the name of Islam and Group discussion.


If you analyze the topic of controversy on the name of Islam one may find these are also some 15-20 topic.


1. Following an Imam.
2. Waseelah permissible or not
3.Position of Hand in Prayer.
4. Ameen with loud vice or silently.
5. Women should come to mosque or not.


etc>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>some 15-20 topics


Characteristrics of these topics


1.Most of them are very old controversies.


2.When Ulemas and Jurist used to discuss these they were having background knowledge of different point of view and supporting Ahadith for position taken by other scholars.


3.Thats why their interpersonal relation used to be good and harmonious, and in most of the cases discussion used to be selecting the best option among the two/three correct position.


4.And both used to agree that on the basis of Ahadith there is possibility that other position also might be correct.


Now the situation has changed.


In the era of Internet and Facebook every one is free to express his opinion Whether he is competent or not.


Still you will not find an engineer advising/discussing about the use of Clopidogril and Aspirin in CVA. Similarly a doctor discussing about Air capacitor.


Similarly Islamic disciplines are very vast subject.That needs specialisation in particular field.


But among muslims you will find that the freedom of expression is mostly utilised on Islamic controversial subjects.



Although in Islam there are innumberable topics for which no controversy is there but they needs immediate attention.But hardly you will find any discussions on these topic, like................


1. How to prevent the widespread and open Shirk and Bidah from the society????


2.What are the ways for achieving our goals from Quran and Sunnah????????


3.Majority of Muslims are not coming to mosque.How to rectify it????????


4. Many muslim Women are not observing Purdah How to start a movement for this??????


5. How to save Muslims from Intrest related financial transaction/Business????


6. Establishment of Good Schools at par with public School so our Children could get education in Islamic Environment


7. How to eradicate the menance of Dowry System among Muslim????????????


And so on >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>.


But Ibless has diverted our route and has circled us in viscious manner.


Muslim Intellectuals/debator should ponder over it and if it is found correct should try to rectify it. 

Common Methodology of fighting among Muslims Groups on Aqeedah Fiqh and controversial Issues

COMMON METHODOLOGY OF

GROUP FIGHTING on the name of


Aqeedah/Fiqh or Islamic


controversial issues

 A common methodology of criticism is FOLLOWING


FIRST STEP


In order to meet his objective one group X will allege the Group Y with baseless allegation.These allegation based on some text in the group Y book. Group X will present it out of context.Will give own meaning and present to public.  


Second Step


The group Y will first try to clear the fact and will clearly tell that this was not his meaning.It has been quoted out of context.Our Aqeedah is not of the Alleged Aqeedah.


Third Step


But group X will not accept any clarification. And will propagate its interpretation by full vigour and by all possible means.Even if group Y will try best to clarify no takers will be there.




FOURTH STEP





Group Y credibility is at stake.They are desparate.
They are Seeing no option.
The group Y will also do the same.Will bring by same methodology some set of allegations. And will declare their Aqeedah wrong.


FIFTH AND NEXT STEPS


This trend and accusation and counter accusation will go on.

BIG QUESTION IS?????????????

WHO STARTED THIS...........


Who is X who first alledged ???????????????


The Answer is it is on rotation Basisand fighting will remain continue.


Although amount of contribution is more or less that can vary.


Who initiated this trend is  History.?????? 
We dont know exactly.Very difficult to trace and of no use as they are not alive to explain their position.But a single group/person is not to be blamed.It is a collective contribution.

CONCLUSION

Every group is trying his best to malign other on the name of Nahi Anil Munkar.The Quran and Ahadith and Sahabah life has laid down the way of Nahi Anil Munkar. 

WHAT TO DO NEXT

1.So all requested to do something positive to stop this trend it by whatever means intellectual or canvassing, pursuance and Special dua is requested.


2. Allah will certainly give the Reward,Even if result is not visible as Rasul Sallallahu Alaihi Wasallam said innamal a'malu binniyat (Bukhari Shareef Hadith No 1)

SOME PRECAUTIONS 

THAT ARE MUST

OTHERWISE EFFORT WILL

BECOME COUNTERPRODUCTIVE

1. Issue is very delicate. So do special dua and Fikr for it in Tahajjud prayers.





a)  IKHLAS/SINCERITY OF INTENTION IS MUST 


b)  DO IT ONLY FOR THE SAKE OF ALLAH AND FOR DEEN E MUHAMMADI SALLALLAHU ALAIHI WASALLAM. NOT FOR ANY WORDLY GAIN...................NAME ................FAME........POSITION


c) Keep faith on Allah. dont be disheartened if result is not visible.


d) Allah will certainly give the Reward,Even if result is not visible as Rasul Sallallahu Alaihi Wasallam said innamal a'malu binniyat (Bukhari Shareef Hadith No 1)





2. If the Issue is not in the base of deen and in superficial Dont make a big Issue. Dont put anything out of context.Ask the group/writer what it intends with it





3. Dont blame any group as a whole for any wrong doing. Blame the awrong action and person concerned not the group as a whole.





4. Concentrate on General people,In Every Group there are some flag bearer. They are tough fellow but hey are only 5-10 % in each group. Dont involve with them. They are to come at last. Conentrate on rest 80% of general population.




5. Dont go after big Ulemas/Scholar in initial phase.
Most of the Big scholars/leader in all groups are good people .
They understand everything. I am telling personal experience from their private meetings. 
They have become feed up they want also to end the Impass. But for them it is very difficult to come in front.
So dont expect from them to come Forward in initialm phase.








5. Dont wait for anyone.Start doing effort from your own level by heart tongue ,persuation,request,timely and scholary reply and dua.



JAZAKALLH and start from now. May Allah help you.

Role of Group heads big Scholars in infighting/controvercies on name of Islam Aqeedah or Fiqh of Muslim Ummah

ROLE OF BIG ULEMAS/Group Head and leaders

For the work on our movement we interacted with leaders and big scholars through different means.

 Following Observations were found..........

1. All Big leaders/scholars of groups are knowledgeable,humble and pious people really concerned about Islam and pained with the affiars of Muslims. 

2. They know that actual difference between groups is very less.They really want that Muslim should not fight each other.And any difference should be sorted out in Scholary Maneer.

3. They never fight with each other i.e Have you ever seen that any big Salafi Alim fighting with Deobandi or Barelvi Alim or vice versa......

4. Even the present day internet article/videos against each other are by low level Alim or Non scholars.

WHY BIG ULEMAS ARE NOT INTERVENING TO STOP THIS FLOOD................. 

1. When we talked ........Everyone was considering his group as victim. That they are only defending the false propaganda

2. All of them think actually other group is offender and writing/propagating wrong about my group.

3.Thats why they are not stopping the low level Scholars/video makers because at least they are countering the wrong propaganda against his group.

4. All of them supported the Idea of Muslim unity but they want someone else should take the lead as the lower level supporters are not aware the correct position they may not support and will be an embarrassing situation and division in the group. 

5. They will give full support if someone else take the leads.

TO get a first hand information requested to meet some Big Alim/Leaders of different groups.And comment your results.(Allah knows the best)

Is infighting of Muslim groups on Islamic Aqeedah and Fiqh has a strong basis

The infighting among muslim groups/organization/Big Speakers an orators on the name of Islam is the threat within to Ummat e Muslimah. Most of the time issues are blown out of proportion. 

Whenever You will ask them about infighting, THEY WILL SAY THAT We have Aqeedeah difference and as Aqeedah is important than any other things so they will justify the ALLEGATION,CRITICISM AND INFIGHTING ON IT.


Before reading further please first understand the SO CALLED DIFFERENCE AMONG SUNNI MUSLIM (ALL OTHER THAN SHIA)


These has been described in these links.
Muslim groups and their Aqeedah position


Aqeedah difference Salafi and Sunni


Salafi Sunni first difference in Aqeedah detail


Waseela and shirk issue


what is taweel.SALAFI AHARI MATURIDI DIFFERENE IS REAL OR MISUNDERSTANDING

Following Imam/Doing Taqleed legal status in Islam

For Blaming others They take the refuge of Aqeedah differences.Every group will tell that the basis of our difference is Aqeedah Matter.


THEN WHY IT IS SO????????????


1. Aqeedah is most important and sentimental issue for a Muslim. So Every group tries to capitalise this issue.And say that other group Aqeedah is deviated and Wrong.


In present day scenario if we analyse the Aqeedah difference between the Sunni (other than shia) Muslim groups all groups are accusing others as having deviated Aqeedah.................


WHAT IS THE REALITY??????????



1.Islamic Aqeedah is very clear simple and well explained in Quran and Ahadith.

2.All groups are also telling that we accept Aqeedatut Tahawi which is the source book of Aqeedah detail of Ahle Sunnat Wal Jamaat. 

3.Except that there are some differences between Ashari-Maturidi and Salafi Aqeedah on three or four issue like Tawassul and position of Mutakallemin (dilactics) their is hardly any difference.


4. If you will understand the Reality of difference and the Projected Difference and will have concern about deen YOU WILL NOT ABLE TO SLEEP AT NIGHT..............Such a big difference between Reality and Projected difference is.

WHAT IS THE REASON FOR THIS MISPROJECTION

IN WHICH MORE OR LESS EVERY GROUP IS INVOLVED.

1.One of the main reason of fighting is the groups are lacking Positive Dawah/vision for positive work for deen. 


2.They think unless they will not criticize other to prove them wrong no one will come to them.


3.In some cases Worldly benefit in the form of public support base and Big Position is close to their chest. It is eating Ummat Strength from within.

COMMON METHODOLOGY OF

GROUP FIGHTING

 A common methodology of criticism is FOLLOWING


FIRST STEP


In order to meet his objective one group X will allege the Group Y with baseless allegation.These allegation based on some text in the group Y book. Group X will present it out of context.Will give own meaning and present to public.  


Second Step


The group Y will first try to clear the fact and will clearly tell that this was not his meaning.It has been quoted out of context.Our Aqeedah is not of the Alleged Aqeedah.


Third Step


But group X will not accept any clarification. And will propagate its interpretation by full vigour and by all possible means.Even if group Y will try best to clarify no takers will be there.




FOURTH STEP





Group Y credibility is at stake.They are desparate.
They are Seeing no option.
The group Y will also do the same.Will bring by same methodology some set of allegations. And will declare their Aqeedah wrong.


FIFTH AND NEXT STEPS


This trend and accusation and counter accusation will go on.

BIG QUESTION IS?????????????

WHO STARTED THIS...........


Who is X who first alledged ???????????????


The Answer is it is on rotation Basisand fighting will remain continue.


Although amount of contribution is more or less that can vary.


Who initiated this trend is  History.?????? 
We dont know exactly.Very difficult to trace and of no use as they are not alive to explain their position.But a single group/person is not to be blamed.It is a collective contribution.

ROLE OF BIG ULEMAS/Group Head and leaders

For the work on this project we interacted with leaders and big scholars through different means.
 Following Observations were found..........
1. All Big leaders/scholars of groups are knowledgeable,humble and pious people really concerned about Islam and pained with the affiars of Muslims. 
2. They know that actual difference between groups is very less.They really want that Muslim should not fight each other.
3. They never fight with each other i.e Have you ever seen that any big Salafi Alim fighting with Deobandi or Barelvi Alim or vice versa......
4. Even the present day internet article/videos against each other are by low level Alim or Non scholars.

WHY BIG ULEMAS ARE NOT INTERVENING TO STOP THIS FLOOD................. 
1. When we talked ........Everyone was considering his group as victim. 
2. All of them think actually other group is offender and writing/propagating wrong about my group.
3.Thats why they are not stopping the low level Scholars/video makers because at least they are countering the wrong propaganda against his group.
4. All of them supported the Idea of Muslim unity but they want someone else should take the lead as the lower level scholars are not aware the correct position they may not support and will be an embarrassing situation.
5. They will give full support if someone else take the leads.

TO get a first hand information just meet some Big Alim/Leaders of different groups.


 

CONCLUSION

Every group is trying his best to malign other on the name of Nahi Anil Munkar.The Quran and Ahadith and Sahabah life has laid down the way of Nahi Anil Munkar. 

WHAT TO DO NEXT

1.So all requested to do something positive to stop this trend it by whatever means intellectual or canvassing, pursuance and Special dua is requested.


2. Allah will certainly give the Reward,Even if result is not visible as Rasul Sallallahu Alaihi Wasallam said innamal a'malu binniyat (Bukhari Shareef Hadith No 1)

SOME PRECAUTIONS 

THAT ARE MUST

OTHERWISE EFFORT WILL

BECOME COUNTERPRODUCTIVE

1. Issue is very delicate. So do special dua and Fikr for it in Tahajjud prayers.





a)  IKHLAS/SINCERITY OF INTENTION IS MUST 


b)  DO IT ONLY FOR THE SAKE OF ALLAH AND FOR DEEN E MUHAMMADI SALLALLAHU ALAIHI WASALLAM. NOT FOR ANY WORDLY GAIN...................NAME ................FAME........POSITION


c) Keep faith on Allah. dont be disheartened if result is not visible.


d) Allah will certainly give the Reward,Even if result is not visible as Rasul Sallallahu Alaihi Wasallam said innamal a'malu binniyat (Bukhari Shareef Hadith No 1)





2. If the Issue is not in the base of deen and in superficial Dont make a big Issue. Dont put anything out of context.Ask the group/writer what it intends with it





3. Dont blame any group as a whole for any wrong doing. Blame the awrong action and person concerned not the group as a whole.





4. Concentrate on General people,In Every Group there are some flag bearer. They are tough fellow but hey are only 5-10 % in each group. Dont involve with them. They are to come at last. Conentrate on rest 80% of general population.




5. Dont go after big Ulemas/Scholar in initial phase.
Most of the Big scholars/leader in all groups are good people .
They understand everything. I am telling personal experience from their private meetings. 
They have become feed up they want also to end the Impass. But for them it is very difficult to come in front.
So dont expect from them to come Forward in initialm phase.








5. Dont wait for anyone.Start doing effort from your own level by heart tongue ,persuation,request,timely and scholary reply and dua.



JAZAKALLH and start from now. May Allah help you.